In 2024, Ladislao Salmerón and colleagues published a review and meta-analysis in the Journal of Educational Psychology examining reading comprehension on handheld devices and on paper. The study found a small average advantage for paper in both types of comparison analysed.
The study also examines conditions that may influence the results. Its message is not that all screen reading is inferior, but that the choice of medium deserves attention in educational planning. This summary draws on the final publication's bibliographic record and the manuscript made available by the University of Valencia.
EDITORIAL PERSPECTIVE
Print Legacy Initiative Analysis
For Print Legacy Initiative, this finding supports decisions guided by the task. Reading a long text to understand it, looking up information and taking part in an interactive activity are different situations. The medium should be chosen alongside the educational objective, the design of the material and the conditions of access.
One useful contribution from the printing industry would be to work with educators on materials that support reading, navigation and annotation, while observing actual use. Commercial claims also need to remain proportional to the evidence: a small average effect does not justify promising a percentage gain in learning or presenting paper alone as the solution to difficulties at school.
Connection to our eight themes
Editorial classification: indicates relevance to our mission, not certification of impact.
The research investigates text comprehension across different media.
The choice of materials contributes to the learning experiences of new generations.
Turning reflection into action
Schools can compare experiences with the same content, observe difficulties and listen to students and teachers before choosing a combination of media.
Original material
Original synthesis and analysis by Print Legacy Initiative, with attribution to the sources. This is neither a full republication nor an interview with the people responsible.
Research article — Reading Comprehension on Handheld Devices Versus on Paper ↗2024 · doi.orgUniversity of Valencia — authors' manuscript ↗Manuscript preceding the final version · www.uv.esJoin the conversation
In which tasks do your students or readers notice the greatest difference between paper and screens?
CommentComments undergo editorial review before appearing on the site.
